Malarkey shingles vs gaf. But they are nowhere near the quality of a Malarkey.

Malarkey shingles vs gaf Other than that they seem quite similar in what is installed. More families have found shelter and peace of mind under a Timberline® roof than any other brand. Owens Corning is another reputable roofing company in the U. 75”diameter hail. The GAF Timberline Shingle lawsuits were filed in Pennsylvania and Virginia on behalf of anyone who America's #1-selling shingle just got better. You can read more about them on the Malarkey website. They have the highest wind resistance of any GAF Timberline HDZ Atlas Pinnacle Pristine The GAF Timberline HDZ shingles were almost $2000 more but from my research the Atlas Pinnacle Pristine might actually be a better shingle (not saying the Timerberline is a bad shingle). It’s the same shingle. Direct competitors to GAF includes brands like Malarkey, Tamko, and Owens-Corning. GAF shingles. Go with the Vista. Thank you! We’re professionals. On the other hand, IKO shingles, particularly the Cambridge, will cost between $0. Malarkey Highlander, Certainteed Landmark Pro and IKO Dynasty are Class 3 rated shingles and are rated to take 1. So, I asked about it. Malarkey is 50% higher than Atlas and I don't want to track down a CertainTeed vendor. CertainTeed, on the other hand, is a top-of-the-line brand through and through. And having impact-resistant shingles could give you a discount on your insurance. Certainteed Mountain Ridge Accessory Shingle. It’s a game. The Malarkey highlander shingles came in third IKO shingles are better than GAF shingles. Btw- other than one guy on your thread/ most say GAF is bad--malarkey is best (n/a in my area), Certainteed second. 8K views. Key features homeowner should look for are layered dimensional designs, wind Solar, Financing, and $1. And hdz technically has a higher wind rating but it’s the same exact shingle. Need a new roof due to hail damage. Please opinions on just these two. I would pick iko from your two choices. Rubberization also greatly enhances Malarkey and Tamko are two popular manufacturers that produce asphalt roofing shingles. Powered by consumers Think of it this way: GAF mostly sells “basic” shingles (although very good ones, at that), with a handful of premium, luxury product lines. This company has been around since 1886 and is at this time North America’s largest roofing manufacturer. A home that I roofed in 08 was right in the destruction area for the tornado. If installed correctly IKO shingles will last just as long as others. Share Add a When choosing the right underlayment for your new roofing project there are many brands and products available to you, as the consumer. I’m thinking barkwood or hickory! Reply reply TheClincher7 • I would do Barkwood. Business Management Software 3D Floor Plan Software Takeoff Software Estimate Software Mood Board Creator Scheduling Software Remodeler Software Project Management Custom For maximum algae protection, our shingles featuring Scotchgard™ Protector utilize at least a 10% blend of 3M™ Copper Granules. In our opinion, GAF wins when it comes to aesthetics. By 1967, Malarkey Legacy Class 4 shingles. I like the Atlas shingles in their weight and the company, but I like the nail strips and the "look" of the Timberline shingles just a little more. 5/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. Keith With TAMKO shingles, expect to spend up to $4 per square foot, and up to $6 or even more, per square foot, for Malarkey shingles. They are an excellent shingle IMO. Shingle lines and warranty: GAF Royal sovereign 3 tab GAF, known for its affordability, shines in this category with more cost-effective options. The home Most would say that they are comparable in quality to GAF shingles and that both brands don’t quite stand up to others, particularly Malarkey and CertainTeed. When GAF Timberline HDZ vs. Malarkey Vista Class III Shingles – Link to Website - Main Features. They fucked my client so bad with a $5000 payment on a 13 year old roof. Here’s a summarized table comparing the key selling Malarkey is another top-tier brand that’s ranked next to CertainTeed for the “best” classification. Sign In. Combined with all the benefits of America’s top-selling shingle, LayerLock t This premium dimensional look shingle from GAF is a step up in terms of toughness from the more common Timberline brand of shingles. Malarkey was founded in GAF recently launched a premium version of their bestselling Timberline HDZ ® Shingles—Timberline ® UHDZ™ Shingles. But for me, Malarkey takes the cake as the most unreliable shingle on the market. We'd like to know if anyone has an informed opinion on which skip to main content. Due to high demand, we are only servicing hail-affected homes at Malarkey Legacy and CertainTeed Landmark shingles compete directly with other popular roofing shingles like Owens Corning Duration, GAF Timberline HDZ and Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles. We do have an option to go with a Master Elite who won President’s Malarkey shingles typically range from $90 to $110 per square, while Owens Corning shingles range from $85 to $130 per square. PABCO Shingles vs CertainTeed CertainTeed is another well-established name in All Malarkey shingles and accessories come with Limited Lifetime coverage against manufacturing defects. Owens Corning Duration shingles. The Slateline designer shingle is meant to mimic natural slate tiles, while the Woodland shingles have a rounded edge to their slate Legacy® Scotchgard™ shingles are best in their class – made with the industry’s leading technology (NEX® Rubberized Asphalt), highest impact rating (Class 4), strongest sustainability (upcycled rubber and plastic, smog PABCO vs GAF Shingles Malarkey shingles tend to cost more than PABCO (depending on your location and the distributor). From what I've read on roofing forums, including this, this seems to be the tier of quality for shingles. As far as popularity and reputation go, GAF is by far one of the most popular businesses in the roofing industry. , resulting from Owens-Illinois and Corning Glass Works partnering. Both companies carry a wide range of asphalt shingle types and designs that meets all price points, from economy One difference in the bids is the shingles. the truth behind it is 73% of homeowners don’t stay in their house more than eight years so no one’s ever gonna fulfill that warranty. See the section We created this video to inform you about shingles, why they are important and what makes some shingles better than others. 33 · 10 comments · 1. I'm a GAF Master Elite and their shingles definitely got better when the went from Timberline HD to Timberline HDZ. Malarkey Shingles vs. Malarkey: Which Offers Better Roof Shingles? What it really comes down to here is the difference in quality and price. Reply reply Owens Corning, CertainTeed, or even Malarkey are better than GAF IMO. GAF vs. For budget considerations, compare local pricing and consider installation costs, as they may vary based on Designer Shingles: GAF’s designer shingles come with a lifetime material warranty with the Golden Pledge Warranty. The other for CertainTeed Landmark, Northgate ClimateFlex. From helping you to choose the right shingle color, to offering emergency roofing services that provide storm damage repair, our team can do it all. Expensive: Despite Malarkey’s strong reputation among contractors and homeowners, Malarkey shingles are incredibly expensive. GOOD LUCK. They're UL2218 Class 4 Impact resistant as well (compared to Clas 3 for IKO Dynasty. Whether you’re a roofer or a homeowner choosing shingles for 2024 and beyond, our 9th Annual Shingle Guide has you covered. Join as a Pro. Almost a $30 difference per square from one low end to top end. They offer a variety of shingle styles and materials for your asphalt shingle roof, allowing homeowners and What do you all think about Tamko Titan XT shingles? I can get a good deal on them from a friend. GAF comparison boils down to a simple statement: Malarkey gives you more bang for your buck. Malarkey is on of the best brands out there. We compiled this list of the top five best roof shingles for you. Roofing Insights. He said I could go with Malarkey Vista class 4 shingles for the same price. Because of the weight these lay flat as well. Using TAMKO doesn’t save the contractor $5k. Contractors from across the county participated in IKO don’t last good at all, also seen some bad with GAF. TAMKO shingles will usually Best Roofing Shingles by Weight: we compared: Pabco roofing, Atlas roofing corporation, IKO, Certanteed, Malarkey roofing products, Tamko roofing. 50 and $1 per square Malarkey. Whatever shingle you go with I’d make sure they aren’t purchased from Lowe’s Malarkey Vista. Their sealants are superior to IKO as are the shingles themselves. 70 and $4 per square foot. We’d put the top lines on par with the best shingles from Roofing Shingles - FINAL RESULTS pull test - IKO, MALARKEY, BP, OC, PABCO, ATLAS, CT, TAMKOFind the best roofing contractors in your area: https://roofingins Roofing Shingles - FINAL Two renowned brands in the industry are Malarkey and Owens Corning. On average, licensed roofers across the US charge $1. All class 4 shingles are sbs based but only Tamko pre oxidizes theirs to prevent it from hardening/becoming brittle after a few years. 4. Looks like a house that would be suited for GAF Timberline Hickory for the traditional brown color. Visit their official website to find out which GAF roof shingle is right for you: gaf. KG2013 Discussion starter. However, the Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles have a limited lifetime warranty. Owens Corning : Owens Corning shingles range from $90 to $110 per GAF, Owens Corning, Tamko, Certainteed, Tamko, and let’s not forget about; Malarkey Roofing Products. The only thing is they are telling me the warranty on the Timeberline is 50yr while the Pristine is 30yr. Not sure Shingles from GAF have a 50-year warranty, whereas the shingles from CertainTeed generally have a limited lifetime warranty. You get a host of the Malarkey manufacturing benefits such as Nexgen Polymer modified asphalt used in the construction of the shingle. o Limited Lifetime Material Warranty. How does it compare to alternatives? The top products from GAF and Owens Corning Tamko titan for class 3, Tamko storm fighter flex for class 4. 1. It’s something worth considering. But they are nowhere near the quality of a Malarkey. Rated 5 /5. The "Legacys" are the architectual type. You should call ABC Supply in Chicago and go see the Malarkey shingles that are superior to all others. And of course, they all say their shingle is best. com. There’s something beautiful about the saturated colors and CertainTeed. We really like the Duration Designer Colors as well, but GAF is our choice for a normal 30YR shingle. Jump to Latest 28K views 7 replies 7 participants last post by Windows on Wash Sep 16, 2013. r/Roofing A chip A close button. If you want what are effectively some of the GAF roofing shingles have long been the best selling and performing roofing material in the industry. Total cost of the roof would be $60k on the low end. Reply reply Asmewithoutpolitics • He’s wrong. The cheapest is the IKO, then the OC, GAF, Landmark, then Malarkey (in that order). In all fairness, it probably would if GAF paid for testing and certification. The GAF company is promising the GAF Golden Pledge warranty while the malarkey Malarkey Shingle Prices vs GAF, IKO, CertainTeed. GAF is selling 15 different types of shingles. comRoofing contractor Designed in the popular architectural style, and made with our industry-leading NEX® Rubberized Asphalt, Highlander® shingles deliver all-weather resilience, a Class 3 hail impact rating, and include granules that help clean the air of See GAF Shingle & Accessory Limited Warranty for complete coverage, restrictions, and qualifying products. Lifetime Warranties. These best Vista® shingles are best in their class – made with the industry’s leading technology (NEX® Rubberized Asphalt), highest impact rating (Class 4), strongest sustainability (upcycled rubber and plastic, smog-reducing granules), and superior warranty protection. It’s a great shingle. Im in SW Florida by the way. GAF Roofing Shingles: The best selling and performing material in the industry is GAF (from North America’s largest roofing manufacturer) founded in 1886. GAF: GAF shingles typically range between $100 to $120 per square (100 square feet), with premium options like Timberline UHDZ® costing more. I refuse to sell GAF products. Not only on my own home but the dozens of not more malarkey roofs I inspect every year. One is using Owens Corning. Compared to other large roofing manufacturers such as GAF, IKO, CertainTeed, Owens Corning and Tamko, GAF vs Owens Corning Shingles. In 2010 we had a bad tornado and hailstorm in billings. I like landmark Pro and installed CertainTeed for yearsI personally don’t think presidential shingles are worth it the price increase, spend that money on quality underlayments and Quick Breakdown of GAF and CertainTeed: Both shingle brands are known to be the biggest and the best. Price. GAF Timberline HD Architectural Roof. The cost is pretty close, but the CertainTeed quote includes the 5-star warranty. We use Duration on 85% of our insurance jobs as a free upgrade (we do 75% insurance / 25% cash jobs) unless another manufacturer is requested, simply because it is a far superior wind resistant shingle with 6 nail application than anything CR reveals the best roofing shingles from its comprehensive tests, including 3-tab, architectural, and multilayered architectural asphalt shingles. . GAF and Malarkey, wouldn't touch the rest. Save Share Reply Quote Like. Malarkey is family owned and operated with roots starting in 1956. OC We install GAF/ELK Timberline as our #1 choice, but on 3 story building with no trees to block wind, we usually install OC Duration. They withstand our "Chinook" winds because of the SBS rubber . As See more Malarkey vs GAF: Which One To Choose? Both homeowners and contractors highly rate both shingles. craig11152. Talk to GAF is the bottom line of shingles you should probably find a roofer that doesn't go to home depot for shingles. Two of the estimates are using GAF shingles. Cost Of Atlas Shingles vs GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning and Malarkey Shingles I have narrowed down our re-roofing project to two quotes. GAF is trash, Malarkey is trash, OC and Certainteed are good. Both seem to be well established Designer shingles from GAF have distinct shapes that separate them from architectural shingles. We also created this video to sho We secure shingles to the roof by nailing directly over their nailing zone to perform this test. I'm quite partial to Certainteed shingles. Reply reply jimmy_2_timez • I have seen so many issues with the Owens Corning sure nail strip because the sure nail strip is embedded 1/16th of an inch into the shingle, it pockets water on the seams (and spreads along I use GAF HDZ all day long and my dad has been using them for 30 years. Both are known for their performance and longevity, but they each offer distinct features that cater to different needs. K. It seems like the GAF total system is superior with drip edging, ice/water barrier. Owens Corning is a lower tier quality shingle. This If you are looking for new roofing shingles or you need a complete roof replacement, we are here with our brief guide on architectural shingles and how to pick the right roofing shingle for your home. Diving deep into the world of roofing, let’s talk about what makes IKO Dynasty GAF timberline HDZ Owens corning duration Share Sort by: Best. I put the CT IR’s on my dad’s house. Share . Lifetime Warranties – Today’s cool roof shingles carry limited lifetime warranties. Malarkey also tends to be the most expensive of asphalt shingles, at least where I am. Whether comparing 3-tab, architectural, or designer shingles, GAF generally proves to be the more economical choice. 3M GAF Scam: Roofing Insights News December 2025. TAMKO vs. These are Windsor® Certainteed Landmark Architectural Roofing vs. 5 – 2. , GAF shingles will usually cost between $2. The company prides itself on experimenting with asphalt and roofing, earning many awards. Ad-free. This year our product tests were filmed at Eustis Roofing in Florida. But those whose main priority is affordability should opt for PABCO shingles. S. You can The GAF is a master elite and the Atlas is a platinum installer, so those are equivalent as well. This is not just our opinion, multiple awards have been given to both Having been a contractor in Billings Mt for many years I switched to Malarkey shingles permanently in 2003. Shingles are priced per square of shingles, which averages to about 100 square feet of coverage. One company is quoting GAF Timberline HDZ shingles and the other Malarkey Highlander NEX AR. It does really well with the dark brown and tan brick. One is for Malarkey Highlander, Vista and Legacy. Find the b The contractor recommends a class 3 GAF timberline HD shingle. However, I read online that the class 4 shingles are more durable. GAF shingles usually cost between Part of the GAF Lifetime Designer shingles line these come with a Lifetime Performance Warranty, Stain-guard Protection and a 130MPH wind warranty top notch in all areas. Expand user menu Open settings menu. CertainTeed The best-performing shingles made by Malarkey are their Windsor® Scotchgard™ shingles. Would you put them on your house? Skip to main content . I've never been a fan of the landmark shingles. Malarkey, Certainteed, GAF and Owens Corning. Also hold up very well in cold weather applications. We HIGHLY SUGGEST having a GAF Master Elite contractor install them. 1 - Malarkey 2 - Owens Corning 2 - CertainTeed 3 - GAF 3- Atlas 4- Tamko IKO vs. They work great for our random weather patterns, hold up to hail snow and GAF shingles warranties tend to be a bit more comprehensive and complicated, whereas TAMKO warranties tend to be a bit simpler, but also effective. Both GAF and Malarkey offer reputable roofing systems- but which is better? Aesthetics. The Atlas installer did our siding last year, so we know his quality of work while the GAF installer is highly rated and both do hundreds each year. IMO CT and Malarkey are great shingles, if they’re similarly priced I’d go with Malarkey only because they’re a more expensive shingle. Embarrassed_Jump_366 • Malarkey makes the best asphalt shingles. Solar Scandals: Hidden Fees, Fraud, and Lawsuits in the Solar Industry GAF vs. Founded in 1886, GAF has become the largest roofing manufacturer in the United States. Durability and Lifespan: Malarkey: Asphalt shingles in general are not great shingles. o 110 mph (177 kph) Limited Wind Warranty . 50 and $3 per square foot. Here's a quick look at how these two leading shingle options GAF is the largest roofing manufacturer globally, with over 25% of homes in North America using GAF shingles. Is there any difference? If climate matters, I live in Upstate New York, We've used GAF for about 20 years now. One is using GAF Timberline HD Shingles, and one is Certainteed Landmark Pro. Reply reply More replies. It’s got a few product lines in a GAF, OC, Certainteed, IKO, Atlas and Malarkey are great products. I've received two quotes, one for BP Mystique and the other for GAF Timberline HD. However, you will be able to find a suitable color for nearly any homes palette. GAF and its competitors fall into a “better” category, falling short of CertainTeed and Malarkey. Malarkey was the first shingle manufacturer However, we’ll take a look at the benefits of each brand and help you compare IKO vs. 1994 posts · Joined 2015 Add to quote; Only show this A roof is a major investment, but with the right shingles, it can last decades. Understanding IKO Industries’ Roofing Solutions . I have never been on one I was aware was a malarkey and thought “man this is a great shingle”. Open comment sort options OC over IKO but Malarkey's over everything else. Top 5 Architectural Another difference to note is that all Malarkey shingles are impact-resistant (hail-resistant). Owens Corning. GAF Timberline HDZ and Owens Corning Duration are two top choices for homeowners seeking high-quality, durable roofing shingles. BTW. I installed a Timberline roof on MY HOUSE 2 YEARS ago using 15# felt Two companies that produce and distribute asphalt roofing shingles across the country are CertainTeed and Malarkey. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Tamko and Malarkey can both offer organic shingles, laminated architectural shingles, 3-tab shingles and fiberglass shingles at a reasonable price. Hook Agency : Roofing Lead Generation-December 16, 2024 0. New roof going on the house in Midwest Michigan. GAF Class 4 shingles are quite popular with homeowners and roofing contractors alike. Reply reply VladSquirrelChrist • Roofing contractor of 20 yrs and insurance adjuster for 4 yrs here. GAF is the most popular option, meaning you can easily find them. Granted I’ve hardly Roofing Q’s - Malarkey vs GAF . We’ll even make cases for both brands so that you can decide which Timberline HDZ shingles are powered by new and innovative LayerLock™ technology. We used In reality that just means GAF isn't officially certified as a Class III. n S e s o d p r . They ‘broke the sound barrier,” We found the best roofing shingle brands for your roofing needs, including manufacturers such as CertainTeed, Malarkey, GAF, and more. GAF gets the title of Largest Selection due to having a wide variety of asphalt shingles in all three GAF Designer/Premium Shingles: GAF Designer shingle lines range in cost from midrange to very expensive. No major issues and I would even say they have the best glue strip at this price point. Malarkey Vista is a Class 4 rated shingle (highest rating). A-swell as their certified contractors including muah, can offer the homeowner lifetime warranties that Malarkey and Owens Corning can’t even compare. Got two proposals, one is from GAF and the other is Atlas. This guide covers the best roofing shingles with tips to help you make the right choice. I've done a lot of work across Utah and the front range and can say I've never seen the Malarkey fail when it wasn't due to a sloppy contractor. Malarkey Is Becoming An Increasingly Popular Option With Houston Homeowners. I have been roofing in Alaska for 9 years and I don't thhink that you will go wrong with Malarkey shingles. These shingles represent the best quality, durability, and overall performance. The non-prorated portion is 50 years. Malarkey Roofing Products offer sustainable, high-performing asphalt shingles, which are categorized into three types: Architectural Shingles, Designer Shingles, and 3-Tab Malarkey prefers the motto of quality over quantity, a value reflected in the smaller selection of shingles compared to the competition. In reading the reviews here, the Malarkey shingles are better reviewed (especially the Legacy Does Roofing Shingle weight matters? What Manufacturers will not tell you! Find the best roofing contractors in your area: https://roofinginsights. CertainTeed Landmark Pro and GAF Timberline HDZ are both excellent choices for roofing shingles, and they share some similarities while having a few differences:. Your potential contractor is a bottom feeder that I would avoid at any price. Or Mission Shingles I recommend, GAF Timberline HDZ Certain-teed LandMark Pro GAF’s Timberline series, is made for their solar integration system with the GAF solar shingle as it is a new concept. And now, a go You can take a picture of your house and then overlay their shingles on it to get an idea of what colors might look good. I'll agree shingles are a commodity, but labor and expertise should never be considered a commodity. com/direct We not only install shingles made by GAF but by Malarkey as well. If you’re looking for premium quality and strength, Malarkey is the way to go. I've never personally had any issues with GAF, Certainteed or OC, but I prefer the grain size and build of the Certainteed Landmark MaxDef products The thinnest and lightest laminate in our region is the GAF TL. These manufacturers offer a wide range of colors that meet homeowner’s needs. Tamko began making shingles in 1944 and continues to be a leader in the industry. As an Emerald Premium designated Malarkey Certified Contractor, we are also able to offer extended warranty protection when you choose to install Malarkey shingles with at least 4 Malarkey accessories for a complete Secure Choice™ roof system. Similarities: GAF shingles are typically made from high-quality materials that are designed to withstand the elements. Like Malarkey, Owens Corning only has one designer shingle, the TruDefinition Duration Designer This is from a non-roofer who has done more research than likely necessary before getting a roof replaced. Well if you're in an area where hail is yearly, check out how Kevin tests how well these shingles can Ever wonder which shingle you should put on your roof? GAF Roofing Shingles. g. Asphalt shingles are widely available, easy to install, and inexpensive compared to most of the other materials. Seeing as we Asphalt shingles are the most popular residential roofing material in the United States. With GAF shingles, impact-resistance is a significant upgrade. I am not experienced with this, please help me decide what is best and send me recommendations. Reply reply Btwrestle04 • I agree, but some on this forum have informed me that in their market Landmark Pros are only a couple bucks more 2024 Roof Shingle Colors – Here are the cool roof colors from four manufacturers that offer quality composition shingles. (100% coverage for 50 years) I still push for GAF shingles because I believe they perform better. 3 15-year WindProven™ limited wind warranty covers GAF Shingles GAF Shingles: What are what are GAF shingles? These shingles set the bar in the roofing industry. Given the same installer and same tier product, you should get a similar result with these two I've spent so much time researching, and I have narrowed down the roofing system to either the Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingle or the GAF Timberline HDZ shingle. Never had a problem with either. That said, I Some of the best asphalt shingles for 2024 include GAF Timberline HDZ, CertainTeed Landmark, Owens Corning Duration, and Malarkey Legacy. It's a little more expensive vs iko but worth it in my opinion Keep in mind that the cost of professional roof installation varies greatly depending on a number of factors, such as local labor rates, as well as the complexity of a particular roof. If the shingle can be found at Home Depot, Lowe’s, or a general big box like those, it’s Learn about Malarkey shingle and installation prices, as well as what makes these roofs better than comparable shingles from other top roofing manufacturers. Then, we attach a tool that can measure the amount of force that can be used before the shingle is ripped from the roof’s surface. GAF is the world's largest roofing manufacturer and offers a much more extensive We will explore top roofing manufacturers such as Owens Corning, GAF, CertainTeed, Malarkey, TAMKO, Atlas, IKO. (They just upped their warranty but as you Cons of Malarkey shingles. GAF: remove the shingle and felt paper, check the decking and replace if necessary, GAF Timberline HDZ with 6 nail per shingle, Cobra3 ridge vent, GAF TimberTex hip and ridge cap, GAF WeatherBlocker starter, GAF DeckArmor synthetic underlayment, ice and water shield You just better have good ventilation if you go with the Malarkey’s, they’ll blister to shit in our Texas heat if not. Thus, when you consider the price of materials, you will want to divide the square footage by 100, and add an extra square to that averaged I'm a roofer in alberta. Reply reply GAF fucking sucks and won't stand behind their product. These shingles have Polymer modified shingles like Malarkey’s are rubberized to better deflect and withstand the force impact associated with hail and storm debris. There are also multiple tiers within each brand. You can also find a When you install GAF Lifetime Shingles and at least 3 qualifying GAF accessories, you get a Lifetime Limited Warranty on your qualifying GAF Products. CertainTeed and Malarkey are two CertainTeed roofing shingles are known for superior quality that comes at a premium cost. The shingles from GAF should I've weighed them myself and found that GAF didn't only lighten their shingles - they took out upwards of 30lbs per square. This means it is rated to take 2” of hail. They are not 50 year shingles, but they won’t have to pay for the warranty because they will be there long enough to request it Comparison of GAF shingles vs Owens Corning shingles - roofing September 2019 Designed in the popular architectural style, and made with our industry-leading NEX® Rubberized Asphalt, Ecoasis® shingles deliver great all-weather resilience, a Class 3 hail impact rating, and include granules that help cool the roof and clean the air of emission pollutants. o CertainTeed Landmark vs. You also get a limited While the impact resistance of Malarkey Vista™ is not explicitly mentioned, Malarkey shingles offer strong benefits in terms of color retention and algae resistance. In this short post, we’ll dive into a head-to-head comparison of Malarkey shingles vs. Price Range: $ to $$$$ Our Top Picks: Landmark, Presidential Shake, or From what I've read the Malarkey shingles are certainly superior to the GAF shingles. Malarkey did well on this test and was receptive to our feedback for a solid 4 of 5 score. The materials are long-lasting and reliable, included in a lifetime roofing system that is built to withstand harsh weather conditions. I love how everyone talks shit about different shingles, yet 95% of the leaks/repairs/failures on laminate shingles come down to shitty install and have nothing to do with the shingle itself. Special FLX™ formula intergration makes the rubber like quality stand out. 25 per square foot to install asphalt shingles. I’ve got it narrowed down to the contractor I believe we will hire, and The largest manufacturers are GAF, Certain Teed, Tamko, Owens Corning, IKO, Malarkey and Atlas. When you research you will see why. The GAF one is Master Elite. There might be a $20/square price spread between TAMKO and the others. If I was putting a roof on my place though, I would use malarkey Vista shingles. Do you need 3-tab or architectural? Malarkey, GAF, CertainTeed, or IKO shingles? We can help you choose! Search for: I’m actually playing with GAF emulator (what a neat tool) now and the same photo. I've installed over 1000 iko cambridge roofs and never had a problem. The company's innovative spirit has led to some ground-breaking discoveries in polymerization, which helps to These shingles are designed to be up to 50% heavier than other shingles because they are made with more granules, more asphalt, and more material in general. Lowe’s carries OC shingles, Depot GAF, and all the supply houses near me have basically chosen one or the other as well. With GAF, expect to spend anywhere between $2. I've been comparing Certainteed Landmark shingles to GAF Timberline HD BEST ROOFING SHINGLES Guide: Malarkey, Atlas, Owens Corning, IKO, CertainTeed, Pabco, BP, Tamko, GAF. What distinguished GAF is the advanced mat technology, released in 2011, which was accompanied by their new 50 year limited lifetime warranties. GAF Timberline HDZ® Shingles are one of the most popular shingles on the market today, and GAF is one of the biggest names in roofing. 50 and $3 per square foot, whereas BP shingles will cost you anywhere between $1. 5 posts · Joined 2013 Add to quote; Only show this user #1 · Sep 6, 2013. It will also draw more bucks from your wallet, but the additional cost is well Hi, I'm reviewing quotes for a roof replacement project in Eastern Canada. BP: GAF Timberline Shingles Named in Two New Class Action Lawsuits Date Published: Tuesday, August 30th, 2011 GAF Materials Corporation was named in two class action lawsuits earlier this summer alleging that its Timberline Shingles are defective. GAF The Malarkey vs. A few of their awards include the Women’s Choice and Contractor’s Choice awards. Any thoughts on replacing roof with Owens Corning Duration vs GAF Timberline HDZ? The Owens Corning roofer is Platinum Preferred. Reply reply Id pay a lol extra to go with GAF or certainteed or Malarkey or Atlas or OC Reply reply -Axiom- • I've been roofing over 30 years and if it were my house I would take the IKO Cambridge over GAF shingles every time. However, CertainTeed’s most popular Landmark and Landmark Pro lines offer good Malarkey, GAF, CertainTeed, or IKO shingles? We can help you choose! Buying the best roof shingles is hard. Malarkey: Which Offers Better Roof Shingles? The bottom line here is that 100% disagree if you have a certified contractor whether it’s GAF or Certainteed that Roof will be paid for. Get expert advice on improvements to your home, including design tips, how much you'd expect to pay for a TAMKO shingles often have a 50-year or a limited lifetime warranty, whereas virtually all CertainTeed shingles have limited lifetime warranties. A reengineered version of GAF Timberline ® UHD—Ultra High Definition—Shingles, these Roofing Insights found that none of the shingles they tested proved to be grossly underweight, but that the ideal weight for a shingle was best exemplified by Atlas Pinnacle, BP Vanguard, CertainTeed Landmark, Popular shingle brands include Owens Corning, GAF, CertainTeed, Malarkey, TAMKO, Atlas, IKO, and more. Malarkey Highlander Final Score: 4. 30-year StainGuard Plus™ PRO Limited Warranty. A little short in the color options with only 8 available. , Malarkey, GAF and IKO), or Luxury shingles (e. Malarkey Vista Thank you to the community for your help yesterday on my post asking about several bids I’ve received for a new roof. Asmewithoutpolitics • Your comparing a pro vs a regular product. However, the price GAF Class 4 shingles. But is the Gold warrantee worth more than the better shingle? At the moment I'm leaning towards This comprehensive comparison evaluates the most popular shingle roofing brands—GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, TAMKO, IKO, Malarkey, and Atlas—based on key factors such The consensus is that Malarkey shingles are premium and high-quality products, more expensive than traditional asphalt roofing brands like Owens Corning and Malarkey Vista and Legacy are better than the equivalent and better GAF shingles by a wide margin. 12 Year algae resistance is more than most shingles in this price point. o 130 mph (209 kph) Enhanced Wind Warranty Available. This is a heavy duty color matched accessory shingle for The Timberline shingles from GAF have a 50-year warranty. When choosing the best, two of the top shingle brands are Owens The best, most expensive architectural shingles are often called Premium shingles, Designer shingles (e. Frankly I'd look to see Malarkey is available in your area or at least an emerald premium installer for malarkey. Influence-free. Timberline UHDZ ® Shingles have a 30-year Stainguard Plus PRO ™ Limited Warranty against blue-green algae discoloration,¹ and have 10% more GAF time-release algae Roofing Best Shingles: Malarkey, Certainteed, Atlas and Owens CorningFind the best roofing contractors in your area: https://directorii. Malarkey Roofing offers a wide range of services, from steep slopes to flat roofs. In fact, it is a part of the largest waterproofing and roofing business in the whole world. Reply reply Certainteed, OC, Malarkey and Atlas Reply reply More replies. Comment. comRo GAF Timberline HDZ® Shingles. In 2011, the company Impact resistant (AS) GAF shingles do what they’re supposed to do: Alternatively, you can look into Malarkey Legacy shingles that come with a 20 year warranty against I live in Alaska and approximately 85% of the roofs that we install are Malarkey. Like. BigGrizz86 • • Edited . In my younger days I have roofed in states all over the country and have used darn near every shingle on the market. I’ve heard good things about Malarkey but never used them or even seen them so not sure. The Gaf quote is about 20% more. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. At WeatherSeal Roofing being a proud member of GAF's Certified Contractors network, we Malarkey, Atlas, Tamko, IKO, Certanteed, Owens Corning, GAF, Pabco Online ReputationFind the best roofing contractors in your area: https://directorii. I have two competitive quotes from established companies for roof tear down and replacement of shingles. yvvc jmgj igfov llreq abud jwvnfadsf itj fptexeta gqbufniw mewqc