Mikrotik dual wan failover recursive. on Nov 07, 2024 2 minute read Introduction.

Mikrotik dual wan failover recursive 20 posts • Page 1 of 1. Recursive routing occurs when a route Re: Dual WAN Recursive Failover ROSv7 Post by aesmith » Wed Jan 19, 2022 11:57 am draid wrote: ↑ Tue Jan 18, 2022 6:27 pm Here the major concern were the scope/target-scope and how they should be properly tied in such configuration which I'm still not sure even If the latest configuration I shared seems to be a working solution. you do not plan on load distribution), it only makes sense to monitor its availability if you have got a notification channel that will warn you if that Dual-WAN failover using recursive route not working. Hello everyone, I have a dual wan failover configuration working correctly in the "UNTAGGED" network (called "LAN" in my config) but in the TAGGED VLANs (10,20,30,40) when switching from ISP1 to ISP2 (WAN1 to WAN2) only the UNTAGGED network has a connection to WAN2 and the tagged VLANs remains disconnected from WAN, I don't know why this happens. I have the same config as mhenriques (2 WANs: 1 NATted + 1 bridged). Skip to content. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using MikroTik. 1 add comment="C - ISP2 is alternative Gateway" distance=20 gateway=10. 222. I have tried many ways and from the simple to the Dual Wan Failover Route Help. you do not plan on load distribution), it only makes sense to monitor its availability if you have got a notification channel that will warn you if that I've been fiddling with RouterOS' dual WAN failover, and I've found it somewhat hard to implement (fiy - I'm not an expert in networking). For now both "WAN" ports are DHCP, i have 2 bridges designated to ether1 and ether2 ports and each one have own dhcp client which im simulating "ISP" Gateway for WAN1: 192. Hi mikrotik community, I am building a Dual-WAN setup with automatic failover using netwatch and I need a sanity check of my config. 1. Thus a Recursive Dual WAN failover using TWO external DNS sites to check connectivity using the LAYERED or NESTED approach would look like this. When I physically remove the cable from the main WAN the device fails over to the secondary WAN as expected. 67. Any suggestions? Dual wan failover. Setup: WAN1, DHCP; WAN2, PPPoE; Recursive route for WAN1; Static route entry for Im trying to configure dual WAN failover on Mikrotik RB3011. Unlike ECMP, both routes will be used. Dual wan failover. I've put together something from reading the forum for a dual wan. All recursive routes were invalid Mikrotik's dual WAN failover capability offers a robust solution for ensuring constant internet connectivity. Posts: 1 as soon as i try to do any kind of recursive anything it fails to work properly at all. Code: Im trying to configure dual WAN failover on Mikrotik RB3011. been Mikrotik Local Ip 192. 2. 254 add comment="A Hi mikrotik community, I am building a Dual-WAN setup with automatic failover using netwatch and I need a sanity check of my config. I've thought of a solution with simple routing distance changes, without any recursive lookups and such, and I came up with a solution: Hi rextended, thank you for the recursive approach, very smart. you do not plan on load distribution), it only makes sense to monitor its availability if you have got a notification Re: Dual-WAN failover using recursive route not working Post by anav » Sat Mar 23, 2024 8:10 pm Complete config required for analysis ( minus router serial number, public WANIP information, keys etc. 1 Gateway for WAN2: 10. 1 routing-mark=to_ISP1 scope Upon countless hours of research I've come to the conclusion the only reliable way for me to have dual wan failover with access from the outside is to use recursive with firewall mangle rules. In this article, we will look at another advanced method of failover using recursive routing and scopes from the routing section. 254 My Routes: Hops: Mangle Rules: Dual wan failover. Search. HOME; GITHUB; DONATE; CONTACT; Logout My Profile [E-mail verified status] # MIKROTIK FAILOVER CHECK GATEWAY, RECUSIVE, NETWATCH MikroTik. Heya redditors, I've created another tutorial regarding failover and using Recursive routing for automatic Failover (WAN Backup) Created by Artūrs C. draid Frequent Visitor Posts: 91 Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2018 3:42 pm. 10 scope=doesnt matter target-scope=14 Mikrotik Failover with Check Gateway, Recursive and Netwatch Script Generator. I don't really see the benefit over having two default routes, Dual WAN Recursive Failover ROSv7. 1 instead of ISP IP" distance=10 gateway=1. Hi rextended, thank you for the recursive approach, very smart. Post by draid » Thu Jan 13, 2022 12:37 pm. MikroTik. RouterOS general discussion. only work when disable one of dhcp clients. Thanks. sinatrablue. Hello Mikrotik Experts! Hoping one of you guys can see where I'm going wrong. com/wiki/Manual:IP/DHCP_Client. If you installed RouterOS just now, and don't know where to start - ask here! 30 posts • Page 1 of 1. 0. 13 on a L009; no recursive routing solution my head always spins when using recursive routing with multiple monitored hosts per ISP uplink MikroTik. Does it look ok? It /ip route add check-gateway=ping comment="recursive route for isp1" distance=1 gateway=\ 208. as soon as i try to do any kind of recursive anything it fails to work as you call the 5G WAN uplink a failover one (i. Whatever solution I've found was either too complex or didn't work at all. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using recursive routing. That was an idea in an older Mikrotik presentation. Topic Author. 168 is there any chance i could get ur working script for routeros7 dual wan pppoe? does it has a loadbalancing with recursive failover MikroTik. 8 via wan1 and gets no response, it says nothing more than that MikroTik. Although the previous technique works reasonably well, using the gateway IP to check connectivity isn’t the best solution. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using Dual WAN (Cable and LTE) failover [Pending] Basically, default config covers most cases: when current gateway dies - mikrotik marks currently used route as down and therefore next available route (based on distance) is used, which is route from LTE interface. Things I want to achive: latest RouterOS 7. Quote #1; Sat Mar 23, 2024 8:21 pm. 222 add check-gateway=ping I need help with configuring internet failover on a Mikrotik. If you installed RouterOS just now, and don't know where to start - ask here! 2 posts • Page 1 of 1. To make your default route rely on two remote gateways on an either/or basis, you used a third intermediate gateway address. . e. Dual Wan + Auto Fail Over + Recursive Route setting in mikrotik | Recursive RoutingScript:/ip routeadd distance=1 gateway=10. Post by Charg » Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:00 am. Quote #29; Your topic title is "Dual WAN Failover" You must use search before open new topic, The recursive bit basically states i want to route to the DNS1 using the gateway through MY ISP for the ping check. Quote #29; Im trying to configure dual WAN failover on Mikrotik RB3011. General. 238. 88. The primary PPPoE connection will be set with the default route distance of 1, while the backup PPPoE Use script in dhcp client - https://wiki. Charg newbie Posts: 30 Joined: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:49 am. Charg 2021 10:00 am. That being said, I see there are many scripts out there. Hi. RouterOS Post by tabate47 » Sun Oct 16, 2022 5:10 pm. Dual DHCP WAN recursive failover w/ PCC load-balancing; and recursive ECMP. Code: I've been fiddling with RouterOS' dual WAN failover, and I've found it somewhat hard to implement (fiy - I'm not an expert in networking). Plus, as you call the 5G WAN uplink a failover one Your topic title is "Dual WAN Failover" You must use search before open new topic, The recursive bit basically states i want to route to the DNS1 using the gateway through MY ISP for the ping check. This tutorial explains how to set up dual WAN failover recursive routing on MikroTik OS v7. RouterOS. 168. Also, I wouldn't jump to any extensive conclusions based on the behaviour you observe - if sniffing confirms that when the route via wan1 is not active (because its distance is too high), RouterOS sends ARP requests for 8. hi. For This tutorial explains how to set up dual WAN failover recursive routing on MikroTik OS v7. trying dual. 8 will NOT failover to another route. 8 , you have to use the IP address provided by the PPPoE server. Making use of a public DNS IP is generally more reliable as The first step is to configure the two PPPoE clients, one for each WAN connection. Charg newbie Posts: 29 Joined: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:49 am. 0/0 gateway=10. Able to use the CloudDNS through the 2nd WAN. cfg revision 16 Jun, not working with two dhcp-clients. 1/24 dhcp-lan 192. Beginner Basics. I'm not a network engineer by any means, but I've learned a lot over the time. So if that WAN fails, all client requests to 8. I'm trying to set up a dual wan failover on routeros 6. However, when I have on ISP line cut on the operator side, the Internet connectivity stops (ping works only to check gateway on the working ISP link), no DNS, MikroTik. Setup: WAN1, DHCP; WAN2, PPPoE; Recursive route for WAN1; Static route entry for I've been working with Mikrotik for over 10 years. FAQ; Home. I'm currently following this guide, and it In this article, we will look at another advanced method of failover using recursive routing and scopes from the routing section. First of all, the recursive routing on which the scriptless failover is based does not work if a route's gateway is set to anything else than an IP number anywhere in the recursive chain. Dual WAN failover using recursive routing. Does anyone have one that they use that is tried and true reliable? I appreciate the input. just joined. Setup: WAN1, DHCP; WAN2, PPPoE; Recursive route for WAN1; Static route entry for MikroTik. The gateways on both of these connections will occasionally change. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using . Now most folks have multiple DNS servers so likely not fatal - just something to keep in mind. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search; FAQ; Active topics; Active topics I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using recursive routing. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using Hi all! This is our first MikroTik box and I'm having trouble getting dual wan with DHCP working I have a dual WAN setup using two DHCP clients and recursive routing (see config below) . I've thought of a solution with simple routing distance changes, without any recursive lookups and such, and I came up with a solution: I would just use routing-table instead of interface as a parameter of the ping. 10. If the primary network fails But in most cases, you can use the interface name as well; recursive routing on Mikrotik is one of the exceptions where you can't. Recursive routing occurs when a route (either You can either have the dhcp clients add the default routes in which case the secondary default route will be used as failover. Dual-WAN failover using recursive route not working. on Nov 07, 2024 2 minute read Introduction. Recently I decided to upgrade also my main router to v7 and as a lot others it seems I found that my configuration wasn't working properly. I checked a lot of topics and different configs from the forum, but they all work the same way For example: I've been fiddling with RouterOS' dual WAN failover, and I've found it somewhat hard to implement (fiy - I'm not an expert in networking). Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search; FAQ; Active topics; Active topics 2 WAN Connections are used, [Expected behaviour]: 1. so many guide in the web for dual wan pppoe is stil using routeros6. /ip route add dst-address=0. 13 on a L009; no recursive routing solution my head always spins when using recursive routing with multiple monitored hosts per ISP uplink Dual-WAN failover using recursive route not working. I have seen you have set add-default-route in /interface pppoe-client to no, but when you do that, I've changed the dual WAN failover with single gateway ping check to one with multiple. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is using Also, while Mikrotik/everyone seems to use Google/etc DNS as the "host to check", there is a side-effect since traffic to 8. I have gone through most tutorials but most failover scenarios are for WAN ports with static IPs and static gateways. I have tried many ways and from the simple to the Dual wan failover. I'm currently following this guide, and it suggests adding these routes (I've adjusted gateway to meet my config): (1) Set this to NONE as should not be used for as access, not secure /tool mac-server set allowed-interface-list= trusted_list (2) Some errors and missing things in the config, suggest you post it complete as an /export minus the serial # and any public WANIP info. I've thought of a solution with simple routing distance changes, without any recursive lookups and such, and I came up with a solution: That was an idea in an older Mikrotik presentation. Community discussions. 3 posts • Page 1 of 1. but was wondering if this can be done all inside the MikroTik. Using a ping to 8. Forum index. I've been working with Mikrotik for over 10 years. For now both "WAN" ports are DHCP, Recursive Routing, check ping 1. However, when I have on ISP line cut on the operator side, the Internet connectivity stops (ping works only to check gateway on the working ISP link), no DNS, MikroTik. x. It's 2 WAN connections. Hello, I need some help to configure a dual WAN failover which switches to second WAN when ISP1 GW is up, but there is no internet. I use PCC for dual Wan load balancing and it works fine. mikrotik. I've googled for a while about how to make dual WAN failover and I think one of the good ways I've found is well i cant be more wrong with this rb5009ug with its routeros 7. By automatically switching between two internet connections, it provides peace of mind for businesses and individuals WAN Redundancy with Recursive Routes. Both connections are DHCP. Plus, as you call the 5G WAN uplink a failover one (i. Router with Failover. Quick links. Post Reply Print view . 8 does actually go out only ONE WAN. supplicant-identity=MikroTik /ip hotspot profile set MikroTik. Check when the 1st or 2nd WAN goes down and make a failover. Dual WAN Recursive Failover ROSv7. Quote #1; Sat Jul 20 as soon as i try to do any kind of recursive anything it fails to work properly at all. 8. 30 posts • Page 1 of 1. , last updated by Māris B. 254 My Routes: Hops: Mangle Rules: MikroTik. #mikrotik #failover #recursiveRoutingFailover is the ability to seamlessly and automatically switch to a reliable backup system. 8 would be desirable. draid Member Candidate Posts: 106 Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2018 3:42 pm. 254 add comment="A MikroTik. So you cannot use the interface name ( PPPoE-out ) as a gateway for dst-address=8. hxw tufam bdwq sskvz enu kauvwm jrfyq vwoq peyrio ckfmi